In Weaken Questions, the answer choices are treated as truth.

In Weaken Questions, the answer choices are treated as truth.

• A. False
• B. True
• C. Sometimes
• D. Not at all

Answer: (B)

In a weaken question, you test whether an option would undermine the argument by temporarily accepting that option as true and seeing if the conclusion still holds. If the assumed truth of the option breaks or weakens the link between the evidence and the conclusion, it effectively undermines the argument. That’s why saying the answer choices are treated as truth matches the actual approach: you simulate each option's truth to measure its impact on the conclusion. Because this method focuses on how the conclusion changes when the option is taken as true, the statement is correct. The other possibilities would misstate the approach, since weaken questions rely on assessing the effect of the option under the assumption that it is true rather than on some other consistent rule.

In a weaken question, you test whether an option would undermine the argument by temporarily accepting that option as true and seeing if the conclusion still holds. If the assumed truth of the option breaks or weakens the link between the evidence and the conclusion, it effectively undermines the argument. That’s why saying the answer choices are treated as truth matches the actual approach: you simulate each option's truth to measure its impact on the conclusion. Because this method focuses on how the conclusion changes when the option is taken as true, the statement is correct. The other possibilities would misstate the approach, since weaken questions rely on assessing the effect of the option under the assumption that it is true rather than on some other consistent rule.